نقدها
Estou meio sem entender o que aconteceu, mas fiquei muito ligada a personagem de uma maneira muito rápida e estranha.
Alot of ppl cried over this book, and after i read the ending of it, i totally understood why. The thing that Sam said in the voicemail really got me sobbing.
This was absolutely heartbreaking. But I loved it. Was sobbing almost every page.
Cried a tone with this one. Written so devastatingly well
I enjoyed this book. It wasn't as emotional as I was expecting, but the ending was beautiful.It didn't leave me in tears like people said it would. Sure, it was sad. And it made me feel emotions but they weren't very strong emotions. People hyped it up a lot. So I was expecting a i-can't-breathe-with-how-much-i'm-crying type of thing but all I got was me staring at my phone thinking "that was sad", stare off into the abyss for a minute or two and then continue like absolutely nothing happened. I wanted to cut Julie some slack in the beginning. I mean, she is grieving and everyone grieves differently. Its a very personal process. But then when it came to the flashbacks, her attitude and behaviour was very similar. It made it a bit frustrating at times to read which is a shame because the story has a lot of potential to resonate with anybody that has had to grieve for somebody that they've lost.Overall this book was good. The representation of grief was well executed but I feel as if the characters needed fleshing out some more. For his debut novel, Dustin did an incredible job and I can't wait to see the things he publishes in the future.
jezu to było cudowne przeczytałam w 2 dni leciałam przez to szybko ale jednak nie zasluguje na 5/5
well there goes my most anticipated release of 2021. this was redundantly and annoyingly repetitive.
I knew the hurt was coming. Really it's a great, heart breaking story.
Beautiful and heartbreaking. This book wrecked me a few times throughout and - of course - at the end.
""Então, eu já havia recebido alguns feedbacks negativos sobre esse livro, mas queria tirar minhas próprias conclusões e simplesmente é tudo que eu já tinha ouvido.\nDemorei muito a terminar o livro, 1 mês cravado, não consegui me prender a história, aos personagens... Se achei 2 momentos comoventes foi muito(sendo 1 momento da morte do Sam e o segundo foi o final, a despedida). Achei a leitura bem arrastada, a personagem principal, eu achei ela imatura para lidar com o luto, por mais doloroso que seja, acho que ficou dramático demais. O fato dela não comparecer ao velório, nem em nenhuma homenagem para o Sam, o ato de se desfazer de coisas pessoais dele, sendo que se dizia amar tanto ele. \nAchei muito dramático e a protagonista imatura. É isso, minha opinião…""
3.3 enjoyed and cried. Extremely sad and cause of that wouldn't really recommend
The concept confused me, but the last chapter made the book worth it. I prefered the side stories to the main one, which is unusual. The epilogue was beautiful, only time I thought about crying.
Bueno.... Mira que odio las historias que me hacen llorar, pero con esta me lo busqué. No sé qué me hizo querer leerlo, pero no me arrepiento porque sabía lo que iba a pasar y que me iba a echar a llorar a mares.Así que por eso le doy mi máxima puntuación. Me ha hecho sentir mucho y además me ha recordado a una historia que me caló hondo: "P.D. Te quiero". En realidad, tienen sus cosillas en común.Esta historia que trata sobre la pérdida y el duelo la verdad es que me ha gustado muchísimo por todo lo que me ha emocionado.
2/5. IT WAS OKAY.It almost feels like a crime to give this 2 stars. I honestly relate to Julie, on how much it's hard to let go of someone you've lost. Their connection had to obviously end, but it felt RUSHED.