نقدها
ainda tenho muito o que pensar sobre tudo o que li aqui. não é como se a leitura tenha sido inteiramente agradável, pois o sentimento de saudade e, principalmente, o de perda, caminha junto com a narração de pátroclo durante todo o livro, e vai se intensificando ainda mais depois de saber sobre o futuro de aquiles. a relação dos dois começa juvenil, pura e leve como a brisa que sopra na orla. logo se torna mais tensa, mais condizente com a brutalidade do mundo real (o que já caminhava com eles a vida inteira). todo herói um dia foi menino, todo herói cresce. todo coração passa por provações e eventualmente pode se endurecer. ver o egoísmo de aquiles me fez sofrer, ainda mais vê-lo lamentar a morte de quem mais prezava.
"ele é metade da minha alma, como os poetas dizem." pátroclo e aquiles.
L ho letto 9 volte. È il libro più bello che esista sulla faccia della terra! LA PATROLCHILLE È TROPPO CARINAAA
#patroclosposamianzinosposaachille
Me dolió demasiado cuando Patroclo murió, grecia no lo merecía. El final fue triste pero Aquiles y Patroclo merecían estar juntos, la vida y el destino se lo debían. "Ve, el te espera"
Me perdí un poco en la trama porque no se mucho sobre la mitología griega pero me gustó mucho y me entretuve mucho. La historia me parece llena de vida y linda.
این نقد حاوی اسپویلر است.
The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller is a historical fantasy novel inspired by Greek mythology, particularly the story of Achilles and the Trojan War. The novel is narrated by Patroclus, who tells the story of his life, his friendship with Achilles, and their journey during one of the most famous wars in Greek mythology.
What makes the book especially interesting is the way Miller brings ancient Greek mythology to life. The characters are written with great depth, and Achilles is shown not simply as a legendary warrior but as a person with ambitions, fears, and emotions. Patroclus also develops significantly throughout the story, making the reader feel connected to his experiences.
The descriptions of ancient Greece, the training of warriors, and the events surrounding the Trojan War create a vivid atmosphere. Miller's writing is beautiful and often poetic, although some parts of the novel can feel slow because of the detailed descriptions.
One of the strongest aspects of the book is its emotional storytelling. It explores themes such as friendship, loyalty, honour, fate, and the consequences of war. The ending is particularly powerful and leaves a lasting impression on the reader.
Overall, The Song of Achilles is a beautifully written and emotionally engaging retelling of Greek mythology. I would recommend it to readers who enjoy mythology, historical fiction, and character-driven stories. Rating: 4.5/5.
Excellent retelling of the Iliad. If you've read the iliad/ Odyssey you will enjoy this even more.
Devastating yet so beautiful, 10/10 will cry again for sure if i read this again omg
Primer trauma y bloqueo lector, he llorado como si me desgarrasen el alma.
4/5 ⭐: Pensé que iba a llorar pero en verdad no fue así, me encantó, solo siento que el final necesitaba un poco más de dramatismo para mí, los amo, mis papás.
4⭐️?I don't now how to feel about this book, like I can understand what people say about this book. but I think because it's so overhyped that it let me down a little and that I had to high expectations. the ending was I did cried, but on the other hand it felt rushed te last 50/30 pages it could be in more details. all with all I really enjoyed the book, for now I give the book 4 ⭐️ but it can change i don't now for sure.
it was well written and beautiful. we see how the characters grow and their bond. it honestly pulled me out of a slump. Patricolas was my favorite character for some reason. Achilles honestly was how I expected him to be as well.