نقدها
MAKES ME CRY EVERYTIME!!!!Today was such a gloomy day, wet and really very stormy day! I’ve been wanting to reread this and decide today would be a good day. However I think the rainy day made it even more sad because although I knew I was going to cry as I always do. I’m pretty sure I balled more than I ever have today. The moment I get to chapter 18, I know it’s coming and i can feel my eyes watering long before the horrific main event. Highly highly recommend, if you’ve not read, does not disappoint! TW: Death, war, holocaust
MAKES ME CRY EVERYTIME!!!!Today was such a gloomy day, wet and really very stormy day! I’ve been wanting to reread this and decide today would be a good day. However I think the rainy day made it even more sad because although I knew I was going to cry as I always do. I’m pretty sure I balled more than I ever have today. The moment I get to chapter 18, I know it’s coming and i can feel my eyes watering long before the horrific main event. Highly highly recommend, if you’ve not read, does not disappoint! TW: Death, war, holocaust
Apesar da escrita acessível e do forte apelo emocional, o livro faz escolhas narrativas que considero problemáticas. Ao centrar a tragédia na inocência de um menino alemão, a história acaba deslocando parte da compaixão do leitor para quem pertence ao grupo dos perpetradores, enquanto as vítimas judaicas permanecem pouco desenvolvidas. O Holocausto se torna pano de fundo para uma fábula moral, e isso reduz a complexidade histórica de um dos maiores genocídios da humanidade. O final é impactante, mas seu impacto vem mais da ironia do que de uma representação cuidadosa da realidade. É um livro que emociona, porém deixa um gosto amargo pela forma como simplifica um acontecimento que exige muito mais responsabilidade narrativa.
Um livro reflexivo mas triste demais pra mim ,o que foi meio sufocante na leitura ( li obrigada pela escola)
La historia es narrada desde la perspectiva de un niño de nueve años que, mayormente habla sobre lo que los niños usualmente piensan: amigos, jugar, lo que les gusta y lo que no.Es una hermosa historia, pero no llenó mis expectativas. Esperaba más, pero también pienso que es lo justo ya que el autor quiso hacer una historia corta sobre una hermosa amistad.Me gustó mucho la amistad de los niños, a pesar de que no supimos tanto de ella y creo que por eso no me conmovió tanto como debería hacerlo. También odie a algunos personajes que, sinceramente eran un asco.Este libro lo puede leer todo tipo de personas que quiera hacerlo y, como la misma sinopsis lo dice, niños a partir de 13 años. Muy recomendable para tener una lectura ligera y que te deje algo en el alma.Me esperaba algo más para el final que simplemente lo que sucedió con la familia, necesitaba más y, si el libro hubiera sido de +400 páginas, sería mucho más sensacional y tendría el mismo valor.Necesitaba más detalles.
To be honest, I didn't find much enjoyment in reading this particular book. I had anticipated a historical fiction, but instead, the author chose to portray life in Auschwitz, or "Out-With", in a rather subdued manner. In my opinion, no words can truly capture the horrific events that occurred there, and this book seemed to downplay them. It's difficult to believe that the most notorious concentration camp of WWII could have overlooked a couple of children talking near the fence. Furthermore, the way the main character, Bruno, reacted to his surroundings seemed unrealistic. Although he was just a child, there were certain details that even children would have noticed, but Bruno did not. The story did not even provide a heartwarming friendship narrative as I had hoped. The repetitive use of certain phrases, such as describing the sister as a "Hopeless Case," became tedious and predictable. Additionally, it was hard to believe that Bruno couldn't correctly pronounce the name of the camp despite having read it multiple times. In summary, I was left feeling disappointed with this book, and I don't believe it effectively conveyed its intended message.