Détails du livre
Description
Genres
Avis
Voir tout This just didn't work for me. It was not necessarily badly written, but short stories are so very hard to get just right, and I don't feel like these managed at all. I'm not sure I can honestly say I liked a single one of them, though I came close with a few of them. And then they ended. Mostly abruptly and without warning, without wrapping anything up, without, I felt, saying anything. Some of them, perhaps even worse, just went on and on, and I found myself hoping they would get to a point, any point, even a depressing point, but they never did. They were also depressing. Now, there are lots of different reactions to depressing things. I do enjoy a well-written tragic scene, but none of these were tragic, they were just bleak. I don't really enjoy bleak with no point; perhaps it is a failing in my reading, but I want bleakness in a story to mean something, not to exist as though that is the natural state of affairs for everyone. Even if I truly believed it was (I don't), I go to books to give me something I don't see in real life. All of these characters could have been on a corner waiting for a bus somewhere; I might pass them by every day. These are the sorts of stories I would write for them in my head when I was depressed and watching them out the window in the rain on a very dark day, and that is not what I want in my stories. They seem to get high reviews from many people, and as an author she comes highly recommended, but I think I am going to firmly put this and perhaps other books by her in the "not for me" category and move on.