Recensies
So like I’m now team Jacob I don’t think I can even read the other ones knowing that she ends up with Edward. Help may be needed after this.!?
Moim zdaniem najgorsza książka w sadze. Ostatni rozdział raztuje sytuację.
the movies really do not do these books justice at all - although the movies are really fun i feel like they’re lacking like the essence of the books but either way im having a great time and will definitely be rewatching the movies once i finish all the books
Oke vroeger was dit een boekenreeks die ik geweldig vond, al herinner ik me dat ik dit boek echt het minst leuk vond.
Livro mais triste da saga, e por mais que eu odeio o Jacob, ele foi um grande amigo para a Bella nesse momento.
[Spoiler Free Review]I'm taking off one star because I hate Jacob, lol! I love werewolves and I think Stephenie had some great ideas with their lore, but damn Jacob... Just no. I don't enjoy love triangles in general, but especially not when it's clear that Jacob was never an option anyway.Either way, it's still a great book. Was Bella's reaction a little overkill? Maaaybe, but I love the dramatics, okay? Her depression and thrillseeking was relatable though and an interesting dilemma for this book.Never forget shirtless Edward.
Un peu moins gênant, mais pauvre Jacob... Bella s'en servait vraiment comme bouche-trou... c'est un peu une hypocrite.
I think I prefer the first book over the second. I was expecting there to be...more? I think I hate Jacob. He sort of sucked once we became a werewolf. Before that he was really sweet and kind, but after he was just downright rude. I kind of missed Edward. He adds funny witty banter between him and Bella and I understand that this book was meant to be a focus on Jacob. But I hated him after his transformation. I am excited for the third book though!
People say this is the best book of the Twilight Saga BUT I disagree. This book was so tough on Bella. Edward leaving. Jacob leaving. The nightmares. Victoria. Almost drowning. Like give Bella a break! The most intriguing parts of this book for me were Bella saving Edward and also how she was able to hear Edward when she was doing dangerous things. Having seen the movies actually helps a lot while rereading, for me personally its easier to visualize events in this book that way.
Although Edward and Jacob can both be really stalkerish, and Bella and Jacob are much too close (as in holding hands) even though she is dating Edward, this was quite an enjoyable read. Still, it's better than the films.
I enjoyed the beginning, liked the new friendships, hated that Edward left and Jacob took premise. Things were made right in the end.